Question Page

How have you dealt with possible overlaps between Product Managers, Business Owners and Marketing?

I was just reading an article by Marty Cagan about the scenario of Business Owners "versus" Product Managers, especially for companies using a matrix organization. Now, I'm living in a similar situation, and not only in the case of Business Owners, but it seems that depending on the side of the organization, the scope of Product Managers is divided more than expected, causing various types of issues. So, I'm curious if other companies, big or small, have also had to deal with this. Here's the link to the article: https://www.svpg.com/product-managers-vs-business-owners/
Casey Flinn
Realtor.com Sr. Director, Product OperationsJuly 26

Ah yes, I remember this article :) I think the key point Marty makes is "Things go wrong when these two roles are not clearly defined." There are two aspects of "defined" to work out here. From a management and org structure perspective, there needs to be definition of who is accountable for what and how these roles should work with each other written down somewhere to serve as a starting point. The next level of definition occurs between the matrixed individuals when you look at these management definitions and define your own working agreements that help you both succeed in the context of the shared portfolio of work, your individual strengths, and all the undocumented expectations that you discover along the way.

The uncomfortable truth is that you can't just produce a RACI and expect everything to work out fine. This is because RACIs try to separate out work under the idea to make things clear and clean, but product work is highly collaborative which creates the conditions to blur the lines.

My best advice here would be to think about what makes a Product Trio/Triad successful, and apply that same mindset to your matrixed partners:

  1. Have shared OKRs

  2. Work together (collaborate) vs. create handoffs (coordinate)

  3. Align early on your decision making process

  4. Create the conditions where its ok to have conflict and mechanisms to resolve it

686 Views
Top Product Management Mentors
Tanguy Crusson
Tanguy Crusson
Atlassian Head of Product, Jira Product Discovery
Laurent Gibert
Laurent Gibert
Unity Director of Product Management
Farheen Noorie
Farheen Noorie
Grammarly Monetization Lead, Product
Deepak Mukunthu
Deepak Mukunthu
Salesforce Senior Director of Product, Generative AI Platform (Einstein GPT)
Mike Flouton
Mike Flouton
GitLab VP, Product
Paresh Vakhariya
Paresh Vakhariya
Atlassian Director of Product Management (Confluence)
Tara Wellington
Tara Wellington
BILL Senior Director of Product Management
JJ Miclat
JJ Miclat
Zendesk Director of Product Management
Natalia Baryshnikova
Natalia Baryshnikova
Atlassian Head of Product, Enterprise Strategy and Planning
Reid Butler
Reid Butler
Cisco Director of Product Management