Question Page

What is the difference between messaging and positioning?

8 Answers
Anna Wiggins
Anna Wiggins
Bluevine Sr. Director of Product Marketing, Content, Customer ResearchMarch 24

Positioning is an internal exercise during which you define the unique value proposition for your product, how the product is differentiated from the competition, and where it sits relative to the competition/alternatives in consumer’s minds. Positioning is a building block for messaging.

Messaging is customer-facing articulation of the product’s value proposition. Messaging is the building blocks of all customer-facing language whether it’s on your site, your pitch decks, or your ads.

In general, explaining this to stakeholders will be two separate conversations. First, you’ll want to align your stakeholders on positioning, which should be anchored in customer, competition, and industry landscape insights. Once the positioning is locked, you can build your messaging and this conversation should be easier since you’ve already aligned on the positioning building blocks with the group.

1449 Views
Vikas Bhagat
Vikas Bhagat
Webflow Senior Director, Brand & Product MarketingJuly 14

For me, positioning is the statement about why/how your product is unique and why it is better than the competition. Messaging, on the other hand, is how you articulate (the words) the positioning to a specific audience/persona. The positioning your create for your product is really the foundation the messaging is built on. 

To get buy-in with stakeholders, I really focus on starting wtih the positioning and getting sign-off from leadership on those key statements. Once there is alignment there, the messaging becomes an exercise in iteration and testing. 

Here is one example of Slack's positioning statement: “Slack is the collaboration hub that brings the right people, information, and tools together to get work done. From Fortune 100 companies to corner markets, millions of people around the world use Slack to connect their teams, unify their systems, and drive their business forward.”

533 Views
Sarah Din
Sarah Din
Quickbase VP of Product MarketingAugust 13

Most people talk about positioning and messaging under the same breath and interchangeably, but in fact, these are two very different things that have inter-dependencies.

Positioning is contextual. It’s simply about your ownable market position. The goal is to answer “how are you unique?” And “how do you want to be perceived in the market?” In practice, this is your core value proposition - and you can find a plethora of templates online for this.

Messaging on the other hand is about how you communicate that position to the various audiences you serve (because it really should be tailored to each audience). It's the actual verbiage, language, and tone that you create for your brand which drives your entire content strategy.

In order to have a messaging framework, you need to have a solid positioning statement/value proposition. And positioning is useless without having an execution plan that includes messaging - that's how they depend on each other.

In order to get buy-in, focus on the positioning first before you start working on your messaging framework.

587 Views
Malli Vangala
Malli Vangala
Circana Chief Strategy OfficerOctober 7

Great question and one that took me sometime to figure out as well when i was new to product marketing few years ago! We have used positioning to get clear on who the product/solution is for, what they are trying to address and what differentiates this solution. Messaging can be a simple one-sentence (or a few lines) description of what the product/solution does

492 Views
Grant Shirk
Grant Shirk
Cisco Head of Product Marketing, Cisco Campus Network ExperiencesApril 14

I feel like every organization struggles with this. Everyone (and every function) brings their own definitions and biases with them. 

Here is my definition of this:

  • Positioning: This is the combination of audience definition, problem statement, product/category definition, and unique differentiation. Ideally can be summarized in a single statement (1-2 sentences)
  • Messaging: A structured breakdown of the key pillars of your message, focused on an audience or launch. This is a framework that is used to develop copy, content, and sometimes targeting strategy. 

What messaging is not: copy.

Both messaging and positioning are internal documents and frameworks. Yes, they provide the common language, but the most effective ones are structural, brass tacks, and designed to give other marketing teams the foundation they need to write great, creative, effective copy. 

The "Three R's" come in to play here when it comes to stakeholder alignment. Repetition, repetitionn, and repetition. Reinforce it at every opportunity, and politely challenge and correct people who go off on their own. 

(By the way, broadly this is the same problem that marketing teams have aligning on Campaign - Program - Tactic definitions.)

525 Views
Christina Lhi
Christina Lhi
Square Head Of Product MarketingSeptember 15

I like to think about positioning as the internal facing framework of how you want your sellers to perceive, understand and feel about your product. Positioning informs your messaging. It can reflect the vision for your product, key differentiators, and defines what your product is. Messaging is external facing - how your positioning comes to life with the actual messaging in the market. The key value props that are compelling to your customers can be thematic while the messaging itself is how the value prop is communicated externally.  

2340 Views
Alex McDonnell
Alex McDonnell
Airtable Director, Compete & Partner MarketingSeptember 21

For me:

Positioning: overall strategy of who we serve and how we do it better than the other major options

Messaging: language and themes we use to communicate Positioning.

And for good measure, Copy: exact words that appear on marketing assets, informed by Messaging.

452 Views
Joe Abbott
Joe Abbott
Brex VP of Product MarketingJune 23

Positioning is the DNA of your differentiation and messaging is how you bring that to life with your brand's unique personality. 

Positioning establishes context (for who? what benefit or outcome?) and messaging is the way you communicate or express this unique position to your target audience.

I'll try using the classic iPod example -

Positioning: A simple, stylish and innovative portable digital music device that appeals to young adults who are tech savvy and have a passion for music (kind of cool, but straightforward)

Messaging: 1,000 songs in your pocket (really cool, concise, tangible, powerful)

655 Views
Market Research that Unlocks Growth
Thursday, June 13 • 12PM PT
Market Research that Unlocks Growth
Virtual Event
Carmelo Abate
Emmanuela Tijani, CWCA
Bárbara Manarelli Vieira
+32
attendees
Top Product Marketing Mentors
Christy Roach
Christy Roach
AssemblyAI VP of Marketing
Claudia Michon
Claudia Michon
Automation Anywhere Senior Vice President, Product & Solutions Marketing
Julie Towns
Julie Towns
Pinterest VP, Product Marketing & Product Operations
Jenna Crane
Jenna Crane
Klaviyo Head of Product Marketing
Kevin Garcia
Kevin Garcia
Anthropic Product Marketing Leader
Kelly Kipkalov
Kelly Kipkalov
BILL Sr Director, Product Marketing
Amanda Groves
Amanda Groves
Enable VP of Product Marketing
Pulkit Agrawal
Pulkit Agrawal
Chameleon Co-founder & CEO
Ashley Faus
Ashley Faus
Atlassian Head of Lifecycle Marketing, Portfolio
Priyanka Srinivasan
Priyanka Srinivasan
Verkada Vice President Product Marketing